Newsmax

Hogan Gidley: Republicans Should Draw Sharp Policy Contrast as Democrats Revive Trump Impeachment Talk

Wake Up America · September 7, 2026

Hogan Gidley argued that Republicans heading into the midterms should emphasize their policy record rather than allow the election to revolve solely around President Trump. He said the party can contrast its positions on the economy, border security, crime, taxes, and immigration with the Democratic agenda, as renewed impeachment talk adds another dividing line in the approaching elections.

Newsmax
Share
Transcript

00:00:00:01 – 00:00:19:27
Newsmax Host 1
Let’s bring in Hogan Gidley, senior adviser at the America First Policy Institute, former Trump campaign national press secretary, former white House principal deputy press secretary and former Republican congressman Anthony Diaz of New York. Hogan, you and I have been doing this together for a long time. The media calls Republicans stuck with President Trump dominating the elections. But they don’t have policy.

00:00:19:27 – 00:00:25:08
Newsmax Host 1
They just want to run against Trump. So why shouldn’t Republicans embrace it?

00:00:25:11 – 00:00:56:06
Hogan Gidley
Well, you bring up a good point, because Democrats have always tried to make this just about Donald Trump, as opposed to their horrific ideas and their bad policies that have been proven to hurt Americans. All Americans, you saw that under the Joe Biden administration, and Republicans have a good story to tell. Costs are down under this president. You see a workforce that is going away from the federal government and opening more jobs in the private sector, for example, crime is way down, the southern border is closed.

00:00:56:11 – 00:01:19:18
Hogan Gidley
You know, costs for gas still cheaper than they ever were under under Joe Biden. So there is a good story to tell. This convention is not going to be just about Donald Trump. It’s going to be about drawing those stark differences that when and lose elections and the differences could not be clearer. Republicans put policies in place that improve the lives of all Americans, and Democrats don’t.

00:01:19:20 – 00:01:26:05
Newsmax Host 2
Anthony, this wasn’t a record scratch there yet again, trying to bring up impeachment. Does this work with voters?

00:01:26:08 – 00:01:46:25
non-AFPI guest
I don’t think so. And I find it shocking. I’m not really sure what polls that these individuals are reading, because the ones that I look at and the ones that I review, the ones that I read, I mean, the American people, they never like conflict and they don’t like when things feel chaotic. And if you ask me, heading into or threatening impeachment only feels like chaos.

00:01:46:26 – 00:02:10:23
non-AFPI guest
The fact is, is that the Democrats have nothing to run on. They have no. They’re all fighting about who the leader is, right? You ask most Americans who the leader of the Democratic Party is, you get a bunch of different answers, but many of them AOC or Zoran Monday. And then you swing back to the midterm convention. I mean, this is politics 101, and I’m not really sure why the Democrats don’t understand it.

00:02:10:26 – 00:02:34:02
non-AFPI guest
It is proven that in presidential election there’s a bigger turnout. And obviously in 2024, President Trump brought out voters that never voted before. And he won every swing state. And that’s why he is president of the United States with an overwhelming vote margin. And he’s tried to do the same in the midterms. He wants to make sure that we keep and grow the majority in the House and hold the Senate.

00:02:34:04 – 00:02:52:26
non-AFPI guest
And he thinks to himself, well, what’s better than to get everyone to get get her to get everyone together at a midterm convention? Let’s fire up the base. Let’s talk about the winds that we’ve had. Let’s talk about the the great successes we’ve had in my administration. And let’s get out there, turn out the vote and win these seats.

00:02:52:27 – 00:02:53:15
Hogan Gidley
Yeah, yeah.

00:02:53:16 – 00:03:10:20
Newsmax Host 1
I mean, Hogan, to that point, I mean, I get it. You know, gas prices are higher than we want them to be. The war is still going on. But you’ve got a million jobs created. You’ve got tax cuts. You’ve got, you know, illegals being deported or leaving on their own. There’s a good story to tell if you just stand up and proudly do it.

00:03:10:25 – 00:03:36:17
Hogan Gidley
Yeah. But also the contrast, as I mentioned, is important too. So we’re saying Democrats don’t have anything to run on. That’s true. But what they are running on is terrifying. They want to get rid of the police still there, you know, still embracing. Defund the police, for heaven’s sakes. They do want to open up the border again. They want to allow non-American citizens to decide American elections by letting them vote.

00:03:36:19 – 00:03:59:06
Hogan Gidley
You know, they want to raise your taxes. The no tax on tips, the no tax on overtime. That goes all the way to say nothing of the fact that their whole center of being is to run down the greatest country in the history of the planet. They say that America is the root of all evil, that we’re the cause of the world’s problems.

00:03:59:06 – 00:04:21:07
Hogan Gidley
They want to fundamentally destroy this country by getting rid of the Supreme Court, getting rid of this, the Senate getting rid of the presidency. These things are all nuts. But there is a large portion of the electorate out there listening to them and going, hey, I don’t like things the way they are. And since you’re promising me everything’s going to be for free, I might vote for that.

00:04:21:07 – 00:04:29:03
Hogan Gidley
The things are crazy, but a lot of people are looking for that because they’re looking for something different. They don’t know the bill is going to come do sooner or later.

00:04:29:05 – 00:04:36:01
Newsmax Host 1
Yeah. And they like to campaign with a guy who said, we deserve nine over 11. So you have that too. All right Hogan Anthony good to see you guys this morning. Have a happy Labor Day.